This past Christmas, mom gave all the grownups in the family the Barnes & Noble Nook.
Yeah. Pretty cool.
So having mucked around with it since Christmas, here's what I have to say about it.
The good:
Its easy to read. Easy on the eyes to a surprising degree. People concerned about getting eye strain from staring at a screen should relax. It's no more difficult to read than a printed page. Plus, you can change the font size when you do get tired.
It uses exactly the same E Ink technology as the Kindle. If you like that, you will like the Nook's reading screen. It's been reviewed to death by more demanding critics than I - so I'll leave it at that.
It makes the impulse buy ridiculously easy. I used to think of e-readers as personal media devices aimed at text. After using the Nook, I now look at them as a Barnes & Noble store you buy so you can invite it into your home. The Nook connects to the interweb cellularly or by WiFi. Translation: your personal B&N franchise is always waiting to capitalize on your next moment of weakness.
It's very pretty. Clean lines and it comes with attractive pre-loaded wallpapers like cityscapes and nature.
It allows you to change the battery and add memory. The merest hint that an ebook seller would allow its customers to (y'know) maintain the device is a good step. It's a very small step, but a good one.
It uses the ePub file format. Meaning content producers do not have to put their publications into a proprietary format. This is good for lots of reason - but unfortunately, this is a benefit that takes a long time to realize.
If you boil all that down - what's right with the Nook is what's right with all eReaders: A convenient way to buy, store and read publications.
The ePub format is a step up - but will not wow any new user because the immediate result looks identical to what you see on other eReaders.
Being able to access WiFi and cellular internet is a plus - but since the cellular access is free (and your average ePub file is not terribly large) there's not a big wow factor there either.
WiFi access will allow the Nook to do cool things that it couldn't do otherwise - but those features don't exist yet. I doubt you'll end up with actual web browsing - but in theory, you could.
Much is made of the Nook's lending ability - but the ability to lend a book to another user for 14 days (once) is unimpressive. When you realize publishers have veto power over this ability (publishers can designate their books as "non-lendable") you realize this feature isn't just limited, it's endangered.
Here's what's wrong with the Nook:
1. The Touchpad The response time for the controls is sluggish. Users can double click in the time it takes for a single click to register. This may be by design - but anyone used to the iPhone's screen will be underwhelmed by the Nook's performance. The scrolling function does a nice job except the visual cue is the opposite of most UI. You don't drag the current screen towards the offscreen content, you drag the offscreen content towards your current screen. Workable, but odd.
2. Search Users familiar with advanced search features on the web will be mystified by the search experience of the Nook.
For example. I typed in
fred anderson
into the search - and here are the first items displayed:
Life of Frederick Marrat Free
John Parker Anderson and d... From Google Books
Life of Frederick Marrat Free
John Parker Anderson and d... From Google Books
Life of Frederick Marrat Free
John Parker Anderson and d... From Google Books
Life of Frederick Marrat Free
John Parker Anderson and d... From Google Books
Life of Frederick Marrat Free
John Parker Anderson and d... From Google Books
Life of Frederick Marrat Free
John Parker Anderson and d... From Google Books
Life of Frederick Marrat Free
John Parker Anderson and d... From Google Books
The Book of Fred $21.95
Abby Bardi
The Dominion of War $9.99
Fred Anderson
Adventures of the infallible Godahl Free
Frederick Irving Anderson From Google Books
There are so many things going wrong here:
a) "The Book of Fred" This tells me that all searches appear to be global. Meaning if you type in an author's name, their name will be used to search book titles, keywords, even summaries. I should be able to isolate a search to a subset of fields.
b) "Life of Frederick Marrat" x7 Why does this book appear seven times in my search results? I should see a single search item:
Life of Frederick Marrat (7 different versions) Free
John Parker Anderson and d... From Google Books
Selecting that line item would give me the ability to select the specific version I want. As it is now - I don't know if those versions are identical, but given the sluggish display, I'm not eager to select each in turn to find out.
c) You cannot filter a search by category. Those search results you see above? You will get them if you search "fred anderson" at the root of the bookstore, in US History, in Asian History or presumably anywhere else. Having drilled down to the the category I'm interested in, the search will include items I've already told B&N I don't want.
3. Bookmarks are cumbersome and unintuitively labeled. I'm reading Tony Horwitz's
A Voyage Long and Strange. Like most history books - there are maps that you like to refer back to as you go through the text. In a printed book, this is easy - you leave a finger on that page and flip back and forth. With an eReader - you need to bookmark the page.
So, I'm on page 239 where the book shows a map of De Soto's 1540 route through Alabama and Georgia.
I select
Bookmarks>Add Bookmark
So far so good. But here's the label that's added to my bookmark list:
17,OPS/xhtml/part02chapter09.html#point(/1/4/38/3)
Seriously. That's the label of the bookmark I just created.
If I create more than a few bookmarks, I'll forget which is which and the automatically generated label is absolutely no help.
Here's what a useful bookmark label could have been
Page 239 "...(Image)..."
If the ePub had bothered to put something like an ALT tag, you could expand that to
Page 239 "De Soto's route (2 of 3)"
That would be useful. Not some URL gobbletygook.
The good news is that these are all solvable issues that don't require physical changes to the device. firmware upgrades and database refinements can correct them without the user having to be part of the solution.
But they need to be fixed.