Nazi Germany being what it was, this was a capital offense. Sophie's inexperienced comrades called themselves the White Rose Resistance. Being young, they took terrible risks and were caught.
Clive James describes Ms. Scholl being offered survival by her Gestapo interrogator. He informs her that her brother and friend cannot be saved, but that she could be spared if she renounced the White Rose and their message. It's easy for anyone to imagine being brave in that circumstance - but put yourself in that room. Imagine this choice is your entire universe:
Sign this piece of paper, or go to the guillotine.
Sophie didn't hesitate. She chose the guillotine.
Her Gestapo interrogator was so affected by her bravery that he told this story to others- it's the only reason we know what happened.
I cannot help but be affected by stories like that, but tragic martyrs give you a hollow feeling. They were right, but being right did not save them. Recorded in history as a posthumous I told you so.
Point is, when it comes to tragic heroes, there's a fine line between being inspirational and being a cautionary tale.
---
Today, my sister in law passed along the obituary of someone who, like Sophie, was unflinchingly noble to the very end. The difference with Irena Sendler is that she lived to be 98.
She studied at Warsaw University and was a social worker in Warsaw when the German occupation of Poland began in 1939. In 1940, after the Nazis herded Jews into the ghetto and built a wall separating it from the rest of the city, disease, especially typhoid, ran rampant. Social workers were not allowed inside the ghetto, but Sendler, imagining "the horror of life behind the walls," obtained fake identification and passed herself off as a nurse, allowed to bring in food, clothes and medicine.She saved over 2,500 people. Kids mostly. Yeah, yeah, Shindler's List II. Seen this movie.
By 1942, when the deadly intentions of the Nazis had become clear, Sendler joined a Polish underground organization, Zegota. She recruited 10 close friends -- a group that would eventually grow to 25, all but one of them women -- and began rescuing Jewish children.
No.
Not this movie:
Most of the children who left with Sendler's group were taken into Roman Catholic convents, orphanages and homes and given non-Jewish aliases. Sendler recorded their true names on thin rolls of paper in the hope that she could reunite them with their families later. She preserved the precious scraps in jars and buried them in a friend's garden.Think of that. She's 33 years old, alone, and in the custody of the most monstrous human beings on the planet.
In 1943, she was captured by the Nazis and tortured but refused to tell her captors who her co-conspirators were or where the bottles were buried.
It is one thing to march to a swift end. It is quite another to stay silent through torture, when each day of silence is rewarded with another day of torture - for three months.
Yet she keeps silent. And she makes it out alive.
And when the war is over she digs up those bottles of names and goes looking for the children so she can keep her promise to their parents.
This language is bankrupt for a word to describe her.
No comments:
Post a Comment